I love art, admire the creativity and the interpretation of abstract thought. However, it rarely creates a sustainable profit-producing business. Throughout my whole career I’ve seen two sides to the advertising world; beautiful brand ads that require expensive production and science-based direct response ads.
If you have seen ads for Coco-Cola you’ve seen brand image ads that tell you the story of the brand, maybe an idea about taste and friendship, then you’ve probably seen that ad dozens of times on TV, YouTube, in Facebook, then extended to billboards, magazines, bus stops, in-stores, etc. That’s a standard integrated campaign model with big brand media and advertising agencies. The model is to repeat the that ad roughly 7-14 times in a couple weeks to become part of the evoked set in the consumers mind, so when they think of soda they think of having a Coke and sharing one with a friend. The model works, but is extremely expensive and limited to large CPG brands.
Unfortunately, most marketers and entrepreneurs see this model and believe it’s what they need to do to become a big business. Wrong. Making beautiful artistic ads that get critiqued more about the font then the message won’t get you the profit you need to grow. What typically gets businesses to grow is the direct-response strategy based on an immediate call-to-action that garners a lead, sale, etc. You need to kill what you eat to live.
“You Need to Kill What You Eat”
Have you ever seen those ads in the back of magazines offering a collectible trinket, with a lot of copy and tear away mail in order form? They don’t look great do they? Well, if you get past the ego portion of it and ask yourself the question “does this ad actually work?” the answer is yes. How else could they advertise in the same spot, every week, paying tens of thousands of dollars in ad space for this offer? Because it works and once it works what do you do? More of it! More magazines, same ad, maybe target the same audience on Facebook with a landing page to learn more then nurture them with the email funnel, Google Ads, etc.
It isn’t sexy, but using data on CTRs, CVRs, AOAs, CPAs, and LTVs vs evaluating the drop shadow on a font will turn your business into a profit machine. Don’t get me wrong, you still need great creative based on consumer insights and visuals, copy, and a structured story to sell, but you need to look at the metrics, test, and learn. You need to be a scientist, an analyst, a numbers geek with a relentless passion to continuously optimize. If you do, you’ll soon be able to spend like the big boys on those large brand image ads… but you’ll unlikely choose to do it.
To learn more about how to set up marketing that actually works, get a free chapter to my new book Marketing That Actually Works; How to Build #1 Brands Fast.
Leave a Reply